I was very happy with the pizza. We got the vegetariana and the salame and we were pleased with both. Closest to New York style pizza we’ve had in Columbus. Focaccia comes with a roasted garlic spread that is delicious.

Gino F.

The food was incredible, we had the meatballs and stuffed peppers for a starter. Followed up with the Italian sub. Loved the staff, they were so friendly. Atmosphere was extremely inviting as well- perfect for Olde Towne 🏆

Abi D.

Straight out of Youngstown (one of the best cities in Ohio to feast) and into the Olde Towne. Osteria nails everything from the perfect focaccia, to the oil peppers, to the stuffed peppers, meatballs and salads. The pizza is to die for, its rare to find a dough so perfect it almost tops the ingredients versus the other way around. Pro bar tenders and drinks that you think about when your on the couch trying to decide how soon is too soon to return. I hesitate writing this review as I dont want to fight all of Columbus for a seat tomorrow, but I will (and I would).

Justin C.

We had a fantastic meal at Osteria tonight!

- Peppers & Oil - Classic Youngstown staple. The peppers in oil were legit Youngstown. They could have been a bit more spicy for my preferences but that is not to detract from this review. The peppers and chili flakes come through nicely. The focaccia bread was perfect.

- Hungarian Stuffed Peppers - Hands down the unexpected star of the show. 3 sausage stuffed peppers baked in a red sauce and mozzarella cheese. Absolutely a must-try starter.

- Numero Uno pizza - Really very good. Everything comes together nicely although I didn’t really taste the hot honey. I’m looking forward to trying their other pizzas as they all look great.

- Tagliatelle (+Burrata) - Like the Hungarian Stuffed Peppers, this dish really delivered above our expectations. The bolognese is rich and hearty and perfect with the tagliatelle pasta.

- Bonus for having a kids menu! Double bonus for the kids cocktail, our 10 year old gave it 100 Stars!

Michael S.

Really great Italian! Not just pizza! If you ever visited the previous restaurants at this location you will be shocked by the new transformation. The new modern design is beautiful and gives Osteria a great atmosphere for a date night or family dinner. We tried a salad, the pizza, a pasta dish, and a sub and they were all great! Maybe only outshined by the cocktails. 5 stars can’t wait to go back.

Neil G.

A must try in the city. Gotta get those peppers in oil!

Dan C.